Blog / Child Custody

Just the Facts: Custody Cases

by josephnivin 

As every parent knows, it is impossible to work together without trust. Custody litigation, by its nature, eliminates trust — to the detriment of the children.

The most basic reason why the current system for resolving custody issues is so bad for children is perhaps the hardest to cure. When parents are breaking up, many assume that they will go to court and that a judge will decide who gets custody. The better alternative is not as well known.

Mediation helps people to decide, between themselves, how they will raise their children even though they will no longer be in a relationship with each other. Unfortunately, rather than seek a mediator, many people currently go to court first. Even when people go to a mediator first, when it becomes too difficult, many then go to court, which they see as the “default” simply because it’s a better-known forum.

So why is litigation so much worse than mediation? First, litigation is scary, and fear leads to anger. Anger leads to the “fight or flight” response, and the fear of fighting over children in court intensifies anger that already exists. Even getting served with a petition that lists your ex as a “petitioner” and you as the “respondent” is enough to make your blood boil.

Once in court, if your child is old enough to express opinions on the application for custody or visitation (in the judge’s opinion, sometimes as young as four), then your child will be assigned an attorney — an attorney who you do not know from a hole in the wall. That attorney has to interview your child outside of your presence. If the attorney determines that your child is unable to use independent judgment to decide what he or she wants, then that attorney — who may or may not be a parent or have any knowledge about child development — has to take a position based upon his or her own opinion about what is in your child’s best interests.

Parents have no say at all in the position that the attorney takes. If the attorney determines that your child is able to exercise independent judgment about his or her position in the case (which usually translates as the child being at least seven years old), then the attorney must, except in very unique circumstances, advocate for what your child wants.

If your child is 12 and you don’t let the child use social media, but your ex does, and your child wants to live with your ex for no other reason, then the attorney has to advocate for your child to live with your ex. 

While the attorney for the child’s position does not take away the judge’s ability to decide otherwise, the position of the attorney for the child is very important — even if the position is based upon nothing other than the child’s wants.

Unless you qualify for assigned counsel, you and your ex will pay for the whole show. You may even be ordered to pay for the attorney for the child, even if that attorney bashes you in court. You may also have to pay for a forensic evaluation, where a psychologist evaluates you, your ex, and even your child, to help the court to come to a determination.

Custody cases can, and do, bankrupt people. The only way to limit the expense of any litigation is to settle the case.

As you can see, the very nature of custody litigation creates such animosity that it makes settlement progressively more difficult.

The easier, softer way is to try to come up with an agreement with your ex about custody issues before going to court. This may be no easy feat, and it may be extremely frustrating. However, for the reasons that you have already read, it is probably easier than litigation. This does not apply in cases where there is serious domestic violence, child abuse or neglect, or parental alienation.

If I have convinced you to talk to a mediator, please do your homework before hiring one. Not all mediators are lawyers, and even those who are can’t give you legal advice. A lawyer can advise you about whether the settlement options being discussed in mediation are fair, and more importantly, whether they are likely to give you a good future. We can also advise you about any issues that should have been discussed that were missed, and whether the proposed settlement has “holes” that leave you vulnerable to future litigation.

Do you have any questions about your custody case? Don’t hesitate to reach out to me with your questions or concerns.

Stay tuned for the next installment of my “Just the Facts” blog series on important family law matters.

Joseph H. Nivin, Esq.

The Law Offices of Joseph H. Nivin, P.C.

(347) 642-0376

118-35 Queens Boulevard, Suite 1220A
Forest Hills, NY 11375

The Chanin Building
122 E. 42nd Street, Suite 2100
New York, NY 10168

Posted in:

Related Posts

A Guide to Child Protective Services in New York

Dealing with Child Protective Services (CPS) can be one of the most stressful experiences for any parent or caregiver. At The Law Offices of Joseph H. Nivin, P.C., we help families in Forest Hills, Queens, and Brooklyn navigate CPS investigations, hearings, and the legal system with clarity and confidence. Our goal is to ensure your rights are protected while guiding you through each step of the process. We know how overwhelming it can feel when CPS gets involved in your family’s life. What Is Child Protective Services (CPS)? Child Protective Services (CPS) is a government agency responsible for investigating reports of child abuse or neglect. In New York, CPS operates under the Administration for Children’s Services (ACS) in New York City and under local social service agencies in other counties. When a report is made, CPS must assess the situation to determine whether a child is at risk. This may involve visiting the home, speaking with the child, and contacting schools, doctors, or relatives. Why CPS May Become Involved CPS cases often begin when someone makes a report to the State Central Register of Child Abuse and Maltreatment (SCR). Reports can be made by: Teachers, doctors, or other mandatory reporters Neighbors, relatives, or others who suspect abuse or neglect Law enforcement officers Common reasons CPS becomes involved include: Allegations of physical abuse or neglect Concerns about unsafe living conditions Claims of educational neglect Substance abuse in the home Domestic violence exposure What to Expect During a CPS Investigation If CPS opens an investigation, you may experience: Unannounced visits to your home Interviews with you, your children, or other household members Requests for records, such as medical or school documents Safety assessments of your home environment Investigations usually last 60 days. At the end, CPS will determine whether the allegations are “ indicated” (supported by evidence) or “unfounded.” Your Rights When Dealing With CPS It’s important to understand that you have rights during the process: You do not have to let CPS enter your home without a court order. You have the right to consult with an attorney before answering questions. You can refuse to sign any documents without legal advice. You can appeal decisions made by CPS. Having a family law attorney on your side ensures that CPS respects your rights and that you do not accidentally say or do something that harms your case. How a CPS Lawyer in New York Can Help At The Law Offices of Joseph H. Nivin, P.C., we represent parents and caregivers facing CPS investigations and Family Court proceedings in Forest Hills, Queens, and Brooklyn. We can help you by: Explaining your rights and options clearly Communicating with CPS on your behalf Preparing you for interviews and hearings Representing you in Family Court if necessary Working toward solutions that protect your family’s future Serving Families in Forest Hills, Queens, and Brooklyn We understand the unique challenges families face in New York City. Whether you live in Forest Hills, Queens, or Brooklyn, our team is ready to guide you through the CPS process and advocate for your family every step of the way. Contact The Law Offices of Joseph H. Nivin, P.C. Today If CPS has contacted you or your family, do not wait to get legal help. The sooner you act, the better your chances of protecting your rights and your children. Contact The Law Offices of Joseph H. Nivin, P.C. today for a consultation and let us help you move forward with confidence.

Two siblings embracing each other

Navigating the Complexities of Child Welfare Law

Child welfare law in New York involves a complex system of protective policies, court oversight, and legal advocacy. When the state, which has a lot of power, intervenes, the process can be overwhelming to all the individuals involved. If you're involved in a case, whether as a parent, caregiver, or family member, you need a clear understanding of your rights and obligations under New York law. With the support of a child welfare attorney in Queens, NY, you can pursue the best possible outcome for your child's future. From a Child Welfare Attorney in Queens, NY: Understanding the Complexities of Child Welfare Law When someone reports suspected child abuse or neglect to the New York State Central Register, Child Protective Services (CPS) opens an investigation. You may face a home visit, interviews, and a risk assessment at that point. If CPS believes the child to be in any immediate danger, they may remove the child from your custody before a court hearing, but you have a right to a prompt hearing before a judge who will determine whether the removal was lawful and necessary. Working With Attorneys for Children and CASA Volunteers Children involved in abuse or neglect proceedings are represented by an attorney. This lawyer is independent of the court and CPS. When fighting against allegations of child abuse, parents will need to secure their own attorney. The court can provide an attorney to those who cannot afford to secure their own representation. In some cases, a CASA (Court Appointed Special Advocate) volunteer may also work on the case, offering additional support to assess the child's needs at school, in therapy, and at home. Preventing Removal and Supporting Family Preservation New York courts favor family preservation in all cases where the child is not in danger. CPS may offer services like parenting classes, therapy, and supervised visits instead of removal. If a court determines that home-based intervention isn't enough, your child may be temporarily placed with a relative or licensed foster family. Every placement decision must promote the best interests of the child's safety, mental health, and emotional well-being. Pursuing Appeals and Modifications in Child Welfare Cases When a family court issues a decision in a child welfare case, you are not without further legal options. In New York, you can appeal a court's ruling if you believe it was based on incorrect facts or legal errors. Filing an appeal gives you an opportunity to have the case reviewed by a higher court. Additionally, child welfare cases are not static, and changing circumstances can lead to different legal outcomes for you and your child. If you make progress in a treatment plan, improve housing, or address safety concerns, you may petition the court for modifications to visitation, custody arrangements, or placement decisions. These legal avenues allow you to continue protecting your parental rights and ensure your child's needs are met as family dynamics evolve. We guide clients through each step of this process to ensure that the child's rights are protected. Whether you're facing an investigation, attending court hearings, or seeking custody of a relative's child, you need support from experienced attorneys who understand the nuances of New York's legal system. Schedule a consultation with us today at The Law Offices of Joseph H. Nivin, P.C. in Queens, NY, where we protect your rights and advocate for outcomes that prioritize your child's well-being.

Lawyer filling out paperwork in his office

What Constitutes Child Abuse and Neglect in New York?

If you've been accused of child abuse or neglect, or suspect someone of abusing a child, contacting a child abuse attorney should be your first course of action. An attorney understands the justice system and can offer knowledgeable insight into your situation. The state of New York has an intricate definition of what constitutes child abuse and neglect, and it is wise to consult an attorney who is well-versed in this sensitive subject. more What Constitutes Child Abuse and Neglect in Forest Hills, NY? The New York City Administration for Children's Services defines child abuse or neglect as the action or inaction of a parent or caretaker that results in serious physical or emotional harm, sexual abuse, exploitation, or death of a child under the age of 18. Signs of Child Abuse Physical child abuse can happen when a parent, guardian, or caretaker inflicts or allows another to inflict physical injury to a child intentionally. There are several scenarios that are considered abuse of a child, such as shaking, kicking, beating, punching, biting, or burning a child. Physical child abuse also includes situations where a parent or caretaker creates or allows to be created a scenario that leads to a child incurring serious physical injury. Child sexual abuse consists of any act that exposes a child to sexual activity. This includes but is not limited to incest, rape, intercourse, fondling a child's genitals, and sodomy. Prostitution and production of pornography involving a minor also fall under this category. Signs of Child Neglect Child neglect consists of a parent, guardian, or caretaker failing to provide a child with what is necessary for the child to survive. This category includes failing to provide food, clothing, shelter, medical care, and proper supervision to a degree that the child's health and safety are at risk. This category also includes using corporal punishment to a degree that is beyond what is objectionably accepted, and the punishment results in physical or emotional harm. What is considered child neglect in New York focuses on the lack of health, safety, and well-being of a child. Examples of this include, but are not limited to, depriving a child of necessary education, not following up with a child's educational provider even after the school has contacted the parent or caretaker, failing to provide proper food, clothing, and shelter, and subjecting a child to humiliation or extreme criticism. When to Consult an Attorney If you are facing allegations of child abuse in New York or suspect someone you know is abusing a child, it is best to consult an attorney. An experienced attorney and their legal team will be well-equipped to do what it takes to protect a wrongly accused individual or the rights of the affected children. Contact The Law Offices of Joseph H. Nivin, P.C. in Queens, NY, for your free consultation today. Our dedicated legal team is well-acquainted with the New York justice system and is prepared to do what it takes to protect the rights of the children of the Forest Hills community.