Forensic Evaluations
Custody battles can be contentious, and the judge may order a forensic custody evaluation to aid in determining the best interests of the children. Mental health professionals conduct assessments of the children, parents, and other parties deemed necessary, so that the judge can see the issue more clearly. These evaluations consist of psychological testing, home visits, review of any documents that are necessary, and interviews.
Forensic evaluators are mental health professionals and can be licensed social workers, psychologists, or psychiatrists. The forensic evaluator will interview both parents extensively and over numerous sessions. Although the evaluator is a mental health professional, their role is not as a therapist for either you, your spouse, or the children. You are not meeting with the evaluator for advice, and they will not be helping you through your personal struggles. These are not therapy sessions, but rather assessments of custody issues.
Judges appoint forensic evaluators to obtain a neutral, independent viewpoint of the case from the point of view of an experienced mental health professional. The forensic evaluator will compile a report for the judge to consider when making the custody determination. When meeting with the evaluator, be cooperative and respectful, as your attitude and demeanor will be factored into the assessment made about you and the best interests of the children.
Forensic evaluators are also not mediators. Their goal is not to help you and the other party to reach a custody agreement or parenting schedule. Mediators differ from forensic evaluators because mediators are there to help guide you through the process of resolving your issue, whereas a forensic evaluator makes an assessment based upon the information provided and reports the findings to the judge. The judge uses that assessment as a tool to help decide the final custody order. While the forensic evaluator’s report is not a final determination, it carries significant weight in the judge’s decision.
Forensic evaluators will make an assessment based on the best interests of the children based on the interviews with both parents. There are many factors the evaluator will consider, the most important being the parents’ interactions and attitudes towards each other.
The ability of each parent to recognize their own weaknesses and the other’s strengths is something the evaluator will look for to make the assessment. While parenting between parties is no longer as a couple, you are both still the two most important people in the children’s lives. When making a recommendation, the forensic evaluator’s main concerns are the issues that relate to the well-being, psychological, educational, and developmental needs of the children. The ability of each parent to meet these needs will guide the evaluator’s recommendation. Absent extraordinary circumstances, it is crucial for children to have both parents in their lives on a consistent basis. A forensic evaluator will be reluctant to find in favor of a parent that cannot recognize their own weaknesses, is unwilling to admit the strengths of the other parent, and worst of all, is hostile to the children’s relationship with the other parent. In other words, the forensic evaluation will generally be more favorable to the parent who the evaluator believes is more likely to support a loving relationship between the other parent and the children.
An important factor that forensic evaluators look for is the ability of each parent to recognize what the other parent contributes to child rearing. In almost all instances, while one parent may be the primary caregiver, both parents contribute to child-rearing in some way. Forensic evaluators look for parents’ abilities to recognize the other’s positive contributions, even when they are engaged in a court case where the temptation is there to minimize them.
Forensic evaluations in a custody battle can be challenging and feel uncomfortable, even invasive. An experienced family law attorney can help you prepare for this process and the questions that will be asked. An experienced family law attorney will make sure that you do not feel alone.