The Attorney for the Children
In many custody cases, the court will appoint an attorney for the children. This is usually done where (1) the children are mature enough to voice their own wishes, and/or (2) there are allegations of child abuse or neglect.
The process of appointing an attorney for the children is often surprising to parents. The parents do not get to select the attorney for the children. Rather, the Court selects the attorney. The parents must make sure that the attorney gets to meet with the children, alone. Parents are often surprised that the attorney for the children has the right to meet with the children alone even if the parents do not feel comfortable with it. It is important to keep in mind that an attorney for the children is exactly that, your children’s attorney, not your second attorney.
In addition, in many cases, the Court orders the parents to pay the fee for the children’s attorney. This applies even if the children’s attorney takes positions against you in court. Therefore, many parents find themselves in the position, which is uncomfortable to say the least, of paying the attorney to advocate for their exes to get custody.
Most people assume, when the attorney for the children is appointed, that they are there to advocate for what is in the children’s best interests. Hold your breath: that is not the case. Rather, the attorney for the children, with few exceptions, must advocate for the children’s stated wishes. You heard that right. Yes, even if the other parent is coaching them. Yes, even if the other parent is bribing them. Yes, even if the other parent is providing them with minimal supervision. The court rules say so. And what if the children tell the attorney for the children that they want to live with one parent because that parent said that the other parent doesn’t love them? The attorney for the children has a duty to keep that from the court, because it goes against what the children want. You read that correctly. The children have an opportunity to have their wants and voices heard through an attorney, and that attorney is only relaying the message of your children to the court.
So, what is the solution? First, ideally, the attorney for the children will be your ally. Cooperate with them from the beginning. While your attorney cannot make your children have a position that is completely in line with your own, your attorney can present your case to the attorney for the children, which can make a difference.
Second, a competent and experienced family law attorney can maintain a professional, diplomatic relationship with the attorney for the children. While this does not guarantee that the attorney for the children will support you, it will limit the damage if they do not. It is manageable when the attorneys for the children take a position against what you are looking for, but it becomes much more difficult when you get into a war with them. A solid working relationship with the children’s attorney goes a long way.
Third, the position of the attorney for the children is not the end-all be-all. Every attorney representing parents in a custody case has argued against children’s attorneys. Most judges understand that the children’s attorneys must advocate for the children’s stated wishes, and that children do not always know what is in their own best interests. The attorney for the children is there to represent the wishes of the children and be the voice for the subject of the custody issue, to relay these wishes to the judge. It is the judge’s job to decide what is in the best interests of the children.
The appointment of an attorney for the children can feel disempowering to parents going through a custody case. However, with the help of an experienced and competent family law attorney, it can help you to win, or be limited to a speedbump along the way to a successful outcome.